There are plenty of feelings about how The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn Part 2 ended. The fight scene at the end was completely made up, not in the books. Of course, that’s because the books are only told from Bella’s point of view.
You see, the book itself does have Alice showing Aro a vision, and it’s that vision that leads to the Volutri deciding that they will not attack. It’s an anticlimactic end to the book, as we don’t get to see what the vision is, and that wouldn’t have translated well in the movie. So, Breaking Dawn Part 2 included the battle scene, and I still have a lot of thoughts.
The glaring plot hole means the battle was fake in Breaking Dawn Part 2
I stand by the belief that Alice made up the battle for Aro’s sake in The Twilight Saga's conclusion. She needed something that would make Aro decide not to fight, but what would make him do that? The only thing would be to show that he loses. Not that the Volturi loses, as I think had it been one of the other brothers then he would have still fought. It had to be that he was going to die, and Alice knew this.
The one thing that makes me believe Alice faked it all was the fact that the wolves were in the vision. Alice routinely said that she couldn’t see the wolves. When Bella jumped into the water, she didn’t see the outcome because Jacob pulled her out. There were plenty of instances when she said that she couldn’t see anything because she couldn’t get past the wolves.
So, that should have meant she couldn’t have had the vision in The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn Part 2. She wouldn’t have seen anything with so many wolves involved.
Aro didn’t necessarily know that this was a flaw in her visions. So, she could manipulate something to make Aro turn back.
Alice needed time to build up the ability to create the vision
How do you trick a man who can see your thoughts, though? All it takes is for someone to touch Aro, and he can see into their minds. Alice would have needed to train herself to make her vision believable, something that Aro couldn’t get past.
So, she would have needed to get away from anyone. She needed to avoid telling her family what she was doing, as that could have made Aro see through it all.
We are told that Alice and Jasper leave in the search for someone like Bella and Edward’s child—someone to prove that Renesme isn’t a vampire child. However, that doesn’t mean they spent the whole time finding them. It’s possible that it didn’t take too long, or that Alice was practicing her vision manipulation at the same time.
I simply can’t get past the plot hole that Alice could see the wolves in the final vision in The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn Part 2. Sure, it could have just been bad writing, but it told me that Alice always created something that would make Aro walk away.
Get the latest movie news and updates on FlickSided.